5 Wedding Cake Myths You Should Forget

Planning a wedding is exciting, but with so much information online, it’s easy to get confused about what you really need. As cake designers at Just Temptations, we’ve seen some common myths about wedding cakes that can lead to unnecessary stress or confusion. Let’s set the record straight on five of these misconceptions so you can make the best decision for your big day.

Myth 1: You Don’t Need a Wedding Cake

Some say a wedding cake isn’t necessary, but we strongly disagree! A cake isn’t just dessert—it’s a centerpiece and a symbol of celebration. Many couples cherish the memory of cutting their wedding cake together, and it’s a highlight of the reception.

If budget is a concern, you can work with your cake designer to find a solution that fits your vision without breaking the bank. A smaller cake or simpler design can still be beautiful and meaningful.

Myth 2: Wedding Cakes Are Too Expensive

Wedding cakes indeed cost more than your average birthday or anniversary cake, but there’s a reason for that. A wedding cake is a custom creation, tailored to your preferences, style, and guest count.

Think of it like a wedding dress: it’s uniquely designed for you and requires time, skill, and premium materials. Cake designers account for everything from ingredients and labor to tools and transportation. What you’re paying for is a unique work of edible art crafted just for your special day.

Myth 3: Cakes Can Sit Out for Hours

Leaving a wedding cake out for too long can be a health risk, especially if it contains buttercream or fruit fillings. Cakes should only be left out for 2–4 hours to maintain freshness and avoid potential food safety issues.

At Just Temptations, we always deliver cakes as close to the reception time as possible to ensure they’re fresh and safe to enjoy. Timing is key to protecting both the taste and the health of your guests.

Myth 4: Wedding Cakes Have to Be Traditional

Gone are the days when all wedding cakes had to be white and tiered. Modern cakes come in all shapes, sizes, and styles! Whether you want a bold, colorful design or something minimalist and elegant, your cake can reflect your personality and theme.

Share your ideas with your cake designer during the consultation. Reviewing their portfolio beforehand will also help you ensure their style matches your vision.

Myth 5: Everyone at the Wedding Needs Cake

Not every guest will eat cake, especially if your wedding includes a full meal, a dessert table, or late-night snacks. It’s perfectly fine to plan for cake servings for 70–80% of your guest list.

For example, if you’re hosting 200 guests, a cake designed to serve 160 will likely be more than enough. Your cake designer can guide you on portion sizes to ensure everyone who wants cake gets a slice without unnecessary leftovers.

At Just Temptations, we specialize in crafting stunning wedding cakes that reflect your style and taste. Let’s create a sweet memory you’ll cherish forever.